Movie Tonic
       Your daily dose of Bollywood Bollywood Movie Reviews, Latest Bollywood Movie Releases, Latest Bollywood Trailers and much more...




«« Video : Behind The Scenes Bloopers Of Koffee With Karan  |  Video : Koffee With Karan Bloopers »»


Movie Review : Last Lear (Review)

7,110 views


Critically acclaimed film maker, Rituparno Ghosh’s Last Lear starring Amitabh Bachchan , Preity Zinta and Arjun Rampal is all set to hit the screns later this year. The movie has got critical acclaim from many of  the film festivals that it has been shown. Here is a review by Variety on Rituparno Ghosh’s Last Lear.

The reviewer does not have much praise for the movie and its story line but he reserves praise for the starcast, especially Amitabh Bachchan and Preity Zinta.

Last Lear Star Cast

 Amitabh Bachchan, Preity Zinta, Arjun Rampal, Shefali Shah, Divya Dutta, Jisshu Sengupta.  (English, Hindi dialogue)

 

Variety’s Review Of Last Lear

A grand old stage vet experiences a tragic downfall when he ventures into his first starring film role in “The Last Lear,” Rituparno Ghosh’s badly calculated behind-the-scenes meller that exhibits a peculiar contemptuousness toward movies and moviemaking. A decidedly serious dramatization of Utpal Dutt’s play, “Aajker Shahjahan” (The Emperor Today), and also partially made to honor superstar Amitabh Bachchan — here incredibly in his first primarily English-lingo pic — Ghosh’s handling is stodgy and dull and calls out for trimming. Local auds and non-resident Indian fans will flock to see this unusual Bachchan project and will patiently look past work’s myriad problems.The premiere of a film titled “The Mask” provides Ghosh’s narrative with a rather creaky framing device to rewind to the film-within-a-film’s genesis: Journo Gautam (Jisshu Sengupta) uses an interview with great thesp Harish (Harry) Mishra (Bachchan) as a vehicle to introduce the old, crusty artist to rising hot-shot helmer Siddarth (Arjun Rampal).

It takes a long while to fill in this phase of the saga, since the action first involves “Mask” co-star Shabnam (Preity Zinta), hiding from her cruel husband by going to Harry’s home. There, it’s revealed that Harry is now infirm and bedridden, with the household run by his longtime companion Vandana (Shefali Shah), who at first treats Shabnam with spite.

Eventually, the women grow comfortable with each other, as Shabnam relates to Vandana how she got to know Harry while making the film. At the same time, outside the premiere screening, Gautam recalls his side of the Harry story.

Pace is particularly slack in the early going as characters and relationships are established across locales and timeframes, making Harry’s first encounter with Gautam long overdue.

A man living in the memories of his legendary Shakespearean performances, Harry is a flatly drawn curmudgeon that Bachchan uses for the personal pleasure of much scenery chewing, declamations and more than a few of his signature flourishes. A theatrical moment when Harry breaks into a Prospero soliloquy from “The Tempest” in the middle of his Kolkata living room is a case of Shakespeare-gone-kitsch.

Last Lear Preity Zinta

Pic : A Scene From Last Lear

Since Harry views the Bard and the theater as almost holy callings, with cinema far down the cultural food chain, the likelihood of him accepting Siddharth’s film offer — to play an aging clown in a down-and-out circus, no less — is a major reach. Script never convinces on this critical matter; on the other hand, the inner workings of a non-Bollywood film set ring true, particularly when the crew works in the stunning Himalayan foothills of Mussoorie.

During a key plot device involving the use of a stunt double for Harry, with Harry insisting that he can do the dangerous stunt himself, pic once again rings false.

Throughout, “The Last Lear” seems to hold to an underlying assumption that theater is a considerably higher artform than cinema, a lesser medium more suited for slick operators like Siddharth. It’s a mighty odd message for moviemakers to deliver.

Alongside Bachchan’s scene-stealing, the ultra-popular pair of Zinta and Rampal manage to hold their own onscreen. It’s an interesting paradox to watch a star like Zinta deliver a good perf as a woman who’s widely known as a bad thesp.

Production aspects are top-line, led by Abhik Mukhopadhyay’s evocative widescreen lensing.

Share Movie Review : Last Lear (Review) with your friends on Facebook.

Enter your email address:

Get all the latest Bollywood News right in your mailbox



Movie Tonic Post Ratings
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (11 votes, average: 3.91 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

      Email This Post Email This Post

RELATED BOLLYWOOD STORIES:


3 Comments »

  1. Pingback by » Movie Review : Last Lear (Review)

    [...] Original post by Movie Tonic [...]

  2. Pingback by the last lear review

    [...] a tragic downfall when he ventures into his first starring film role in &147The last Lear,&148 …http://movietonic.com/2007/09/13/movie-review-last-lear-review/Strine Speaks as Delaware Decision Makes Waves New York TimesThere have been plenty of comments on [...]

  3. Comment by Vikas

    I was quite excited about the movie but a few errors on part of the actors and director/editing let me down.

    1. When Harry is asking Preity to slap him and she is not interested. The next moment he is teaching her how to shout accross the valley. What happened in between… it looks like a bad edit job.
    2. When Amitabh is imploring Sid to allow him to do the climax scene, he over does the begging bit. The kind of idiosyncratic person that he is, he should have done that without sounding like he is groveling.
    3. In the last shot, when he is reciting from Shakespeare from the sick bed with Preity by his side, there is a bad edit job. the scene is cut abruptly without any continuity. Bad edit. Glaringly bad.

    Movie could have been nicer if care had been taken for such small mistakes..Not the kind of movie I was expecting…
    Vikas

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

If you want to leave a feedback to this post or to some other user´s comment, simply fill out the form below.

(required)

(required)


«« Video : Behind The Scenes Bloopers Of Koffee With Karan  |  Video : Koffee With Karan Bloopers »»